Take the 2-minute tour ×
Graphic Design Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for Graphic Design professionals, students, and enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Being a webdesigner I learned that Green= 00FF00 Blue= 0000FF Red= FF0000 Yellow=FFFF00 Correct ?

And color theory says that Red is the complementary color of Green. Yet when I use http://kuler.adobe.com/ I get FF007F which is still far from Red. However when I use http://www.colorschemer.com/ I get true Red. For Yellow kuler gives me 7D00FF while colorshemer gives me 8800CC which are different enough for the naked eye to notice. For Blue kuler gives me FFD100 while colorshemer gives me FFBD00

A third tool colorschemedesigner.com give slightly different values (once adjusted to max saturation & brightness).

So as you can imagine, I'm confused as to what are the values of the complementary colors that aren't easy to guess with hex such as Orange and Violet and which color wheel is the most faithful.

share|improve this question

4 Answers 4

I think you should be using RGB complements (in the "Light" answer). The RYB complements were from an era when people didn't know of light's primary colors being RGB. RGB complements look nicer, in my opinion. Here's some random person's (Lira) post (perhaps someone can give me a more credible source?):

RYB is the traditional colour wheel, used by artists. Sir Isaac Newton was the first one to come up with this sort of thing. And it was kind of fun. Here, take a look:

enter image description here

Recognise it? It's the colour wheel Jason Beaird used in his "Color for Coders" article. Remember that, when we're in kindergarten and stuff, we're taught stuff like "Yellow plus Red equals Orange"? It all comes from this colour wheel, whose primary colours are red, yellow and blue (they're touching the darker triangle, poiting upwards). Warm colours occupy half of the space and cold colours the other half. That's like a colour Yin Yang. Almost too perfect to be true.

Indeed, it was too perfect to be true.

Scientists then find out that biologically, it doesn't really work that way. Anyway, after studying, researching, analysing, chopping and cooking colours, we ended up having the RGB colour model, ubiquitously present in stuff like computer monitors, TV's and so on.

As you might be assuming, the colour wheels are a bit different. The opposite of "red" in the RYB colour wheel is "green", whereas the opposite of "red" in the RGB colour wheel is cyan - you can test the latter by staring at something red (focus, try not to blink) and then looking at a white surfice: the afterimage is cyan. Here's an example:

http://faculty.washington.edu/chudler/after.html

That means you have two different colour wheels to choose your colours from. So, which one of them do you guys prefer?


Light:

The definition of a complementary color is this:

if color = {"RR", "GG", "BB"}
then color.complement = {FF - "RR", FF - "GG", FF - "BB"}

Meaning:

if color = {12, 4A, FF}
then color.complement = {FF - 12, FF - 4A, FF-FF}

Calculating the values:

color.complement = {ED, B5, 00}

That's it. Adobe is wrong; they're probably giving you something that "looks nice", in their opinion - NOT the true complement.


Or, if you're lazy, you'll simply do this:

color = 124AFF
color.complement = FFFFFF - 124AFF
color.complement = EDB500

Microsoft Calculator Plus or Windows7 Calculator (both in Programmer Mode) can do this for you.

Here, I made a small quick web "app": http://jsfiddle.net/rXsAT/

Looks like someone already made a nicer version.


Pigments:

Working on it...

Perhaps it's:

{FF - RR, FF - (RR + BB)/2, FF - BB} ???

Gotta do my homework, I'll work on it tomorrow.


Test cases (for me):

  • Red FF0000 vs Green 00FF00

  • Blue 0000FF vs Orange FF7F00

  • Yellow FFFF00 vs Violet 6F00FF

    (Purple is 800080 or 7F007F, which is better, I think...?)

share|improve this answer
    
Thx for the formula, but I'm looking for a tool that would tell me the answer from the color I picked, just like those color wheels but one that is truthful. –  user855 Mar 16 '11 at 2:15
    
@user855 Do you have Google Chrome? Maybe I'll make an extension for that. –  muntoo Mar 16 '11 at 2:18
    
Thx again for you web app but gain this is not what I'm looking for. BTW, FFFFFF - 0000FF = FFFF00 meaning Blue's complementary color is Yellow, which is false. –  user855 Mar 16 '11 at 2:53
    
@user855 I just realized this is true for light, not "pigments". I'm working on that... –  muntoo Mar 16 '11 at 3:21
1  
You should accept this answer ;) –  Dan Hanly Mar 16 '11 at 14:03

Colour scheme generators such as Kuler don't give you the exact values because they are focused on giving you a scheme and they are design based. A colour scheme of the exact opposites would look rather garish and over the top. Kuler is a tool to allow you to contrast colours whilst still keeping the scheme looking nice.

Summary: If you want a true colour conversion tool, don't use a colour scheme generator, because they are focused on getting things to look nice for you, not to give you exact measurements.

share|improve this answer
1  
right, and don't focus too much on it because your grandmother's crt is not going to render them anywhere near your chosen value anyhow –  horatio Mar 16 '11 at 14:14
    
@horatio I hear that, brother! If it's not "web-safe" then at least make some attempt to reconsider. –  Dan Hanly Mar 16 '11 at 14:19
    
How could color scheme generators give a nicer result since there's only one color theory ?! and the aim of this theory is to tell what colors are harmonious together ! Anyway, which tool am I supposed to use then ? Do you too use a biased tool ? –  user855 Mar 16 '11 at 15:39
    
If I had to guess, they will quite often lower the intensity of some colours or add more black to the colour to give it a bit more/less contrast. They are based upon a "leading" colour and then (in kulers case) 4 sub-colours. The use of this tool is almost strictly for websites where one colour would be the focal point and then darker variations and lighter variations of it's colour wheel opposite (depending on what scheme type you choe) will be used in many ways to accent that colour. It's true that if you had 2 leading colours they would be exact opposites but that's not quite how it works –  Dan Hanly Mar 16 '11 at 15:51
    
They wouldn't give you a colour that would overpower your leading colour whether it's a colour wheel opposite or not. –  Dan Hanly Mar 16 '11 at 15:52

There is a lot of confusion over various color models because the physics of color and light and the biology of the eye were not well understood when the predominant theories emerged in the arts. The red, yellow, blue model is a holdover from years of trial and error with imperfect (and hard to find/expensive) pigments that is useful to a point, but is not entirely accurate.

You can use any three colors to define what's called a color gamut, a subset of all possible colors (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gamut). These colors make up a triangle with each one marking out a point. You can then combine these colors to make all possible colors inside the triangle, but you can never make a color that falls outside the triangle, so, in whatever medium you're working in, you want to choose colors that are as far apart as possible to make the widest gamut. Whatever three colors you use are called the primary colors of your color system.

When you're working with light, the colors that make the widest gamut are red, green and blue, so these are called the primary colors of light. This system is called additive color because you start with black (darkness) and add different amounts of red, green and blue to make the various colors. When you have equal parts of all three, you get white. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Additive_color)

If you're working with ink or dyes or paint, the widest gamut uses cyan, magenta and yellow. This system is called subtractive color because you start with white (say, a piece of paper that reflects all light evenly) and the pigments you add absorb light, keeping some color from reflecting off the paper. So a cyan ink really just absorbs red, leaving the green and blue light to reflect. When you have equal amounts of all three, you get black. (The reason for k - black - in the cmyk system is that the inks are imperfect - don't absorb all of the light they should - and adding a black ink makes the darks darker.) (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Subtractive_color)

Turns out that because the subtractive system absorbs the light from the additive system, the primary colors of light are the compliments of the primary colors of ink and vice versa.

On the web, you're using light (generated from the computer monitor) so you should think of red (#ff0000), green (#00ff00) and blue (#0000ff) as the primary colors and cyan (#00ffff), magenta (#ff00ff) and yellow (#ffff00) as the complimentary colors.

share|improve this answer

Ok I'm answering myself:

For documents to be displayed by a light system such as screens, the RGB color model should be used. It tells us what are the complementary colors for the three primary colors: Cyan for Red, Magenta for Green, Yellow for Blue.

Now if you want a tool that tells you which color is the complement of the color you picked, you first need to verify that whatever tool you chose, its color wheel gives the same result as the RGB model. One such tool for Mac is Painter's Picker (a plugin for Apple's Color Picker). Color schemer tools however usually give false results. Basically, any tool that can invert a color can tell you the complementary color (most complex image editing softwares have such feature, it's also built in Mac OS X Universal Access preferences).

RGB

share|improve this answer
2  
Out of curiosity, is there a particular reason that you posted your own answer instead of accepting one of the other answers? muntoo & James Kelly both answered your question of "what are the true complementary colors?" and Daniel Hanly explained nicely why Kuler and CSD don't give you pure complementary values. –  Farray Sep 6 '11 at 17:52
    
@Farray I was looking for a tool (the right one). –  user855 Sep 9 '11 at 5:02

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.