Take the 2-minute tour ×
Graphic Design Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for Graphic Design professionals, students, and enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I use illustrator a lot and I'm always exporting PDFs. Since the PDF is a "save as" rather than an export, I end up editing the PDF and saving out. This causes version conflicts. Could I just work in PDF? What would be lost if I never used the ai format?

share|improve this question
    
I personally have been working with AI saving out PDF (with AI Editing checkbox enabled) with files that are 80 megabytes large and never had a PDF corruption problem yet. I also use both Time Machine and Dropbox which both allow me to restore files pretty quickly if they do get corrupted. Just my two cents. –  Noel Saw Apr 15 at 2:58

1 Answer 1

Can you? Sure you can. Should you? Probably not, but it depends a great deal on the artwork and what version of PDF you save to.

You may find when saving to PDF that more advanced appearance settings may get flattened. PDFs don't link to assets, they embed everything - so placed images would be embedded at all times. You may also find that type objects may get converted to outlines. Whether or not these issues affect your work, only you can decide.

Here's the thing, if you save an Illustrator file with the default settings in tact (PDF compatibility on), you actually save 2 files - the .ai and a .pdf in the same container. You can simply open .ai files in Acrobat. If you save a PDF with "Maintain Illustrator Editing Capabilities" checked, you essentially reverse the priority of the two file types and set them to .pdf then .ai. So you still have two file types but now in a .pdf container.

The issue with the two file types is that should there be an issue with the file, the first thing the app (AI or Acrobat) will do to try and repair a file is delete any non-priority file information. So, for example, say you save everything as a .pdf. Then for some reason a file gets damaged. You try and open it in Illustrator, you may end up only getting the PDF data and losing all the native AI data since PDF data is set as the primary data. Again, whether or not this is an issue, only you can determine based upon your artwork.

I, personally, would never trust the PDF format to retain everything I do in Illustrator. Not to mention the fact that linked assets don't exist in a PDF, everything is embedded.

Quite honestly better file management will help a great deal. Similar to how you would have a layered Photoshop file then send clients jpgs, you would never edit the jpg. Using Illustrator in this manner helps a great deal. Always go back to the native AI file. Any PDFs saved would be for client delivery only. So once sent, you could file those away or even simply trash the pdfs and retain only the Illustrator file.

While the PDF format has come a long way, it was never intended as an editing format so it will often change objects to ensure proper output rather than easy edit construction. If you want to ensure you always have fully editable files, you really should save to the native application format.

share|improve this answer
    
Very detailed and helpful explanation, I was contemplating using the workflow of PDF as a native file format myself - but it sounds like it is not advisable. I've had OK luck saving to PDF with simple files - things like logos and diagrams. It's a tempting workflow because you the designer can still edit the file, and clients and the general office crowd can all view it, but they can't alter it. I wasn't aware that Acrobat could view .ai files so transparently - good to know. I guess I'll stick with the .ai as master-file workflow like you suggest. –  user14190 Jul 22 '13 at 1:40

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.