106 reputation
17
bio website
location Chicago, IL
age
visits member for 1 year, 3 months
seen Sep 27 '12 at 18:27
stats profile views 4

Mar
25
awarded  Notable Question
Sep
27
awarded  Popular Question
Jul
17
awarded  Scholar
Jul
17
accepted All PDF's appear to be 72 dpi, no matter what
Jul
17
awarded  Citizen Patrol
Feb
9
awarded  Commentator
Feb
9
comment All PDF's appear to be 72 dpi, no matter what
@DAO, I don't believe I'm grasping onto anything from the old world, AFAIK... I mainly deal with graphics for websites and measuring in pixels alone suits me just fine. I just don't have the expertise to speak on the traditions and conventions of the professional printing world.
Feb
9
comment All PDF's appear to be 72 dpi, no matter what
@DA01, that may be the case and it explains a lot. However, when I inspected my PDF created from a 3300 x 2550 pixel source, I did not expect to see a size of "792 x 612". Those smaller dimensions would exactly correspond to a shift from 300 dpi to 72 dpi using the same 11" x 8.5" paper size. As it turns out, "792 x 612" is 'points' and not pixels, hence my original confusion.
Feb
8
comment All PDF's appear to be 72 dpi, no matter what
It's a 3300 x 2550 pixel file set to 300 dpi yielding a 11 x 8.5 canvas. So as long as those dimensions in Photoshop are what I want, the PDF should be adequate (provided there is no down-samplings setting), right? By "adequate", I'm expecting to be able to print to 11 x 8.5 inches with the equivalent of 300 "dots" per inch of paper.
Feb
8
comment All PDF's appear to be 72 dpi, no matter what
+1, Yes, exactly. Sadly, I knew all this... it just took all day to realize I was not looking at pixel dimensions in the "Get Info" box. Apple should really have it labeled better in there. "Get info" on the PSD shows "3300 x 2550"... again without any units. Being so used to seeing numbers representing pixels, I guess I just naturally expected those numbers to always represent pixels.
Feb
8
awarded  Student
Feb
8
awarded  Editor
Feb
8
revised All PDF's appear to be 72 dpi, no matter what
edited title
Feb
8
answered All PDF's appear to be 72 dpi, no matter what
Feb
8
awarded  Supporter
Feb
8
comment All PDF's appear to be 72 dpi, no matter what
@e100: I think I figured out what's actually happening and I'll post as an answer shortly.
Feb
8
comment All PDF's appear to be 72 dpi, no matter what
@e100: I started with 300 dpi. Then to play it safe and see if it made any difference, I selected "no compression". It made no difference.
Feb
8
comment All PDF's appear to be 72 dpi, no matter what
@e100: I can't comment on what those profiles are supposed to do. All I can tell you is that they take a 300 dpi original and save it as a 72 dpi PDF.
Feb
8
comment All PDF's appear to be 72 dpi, no matter what
@e100: Yes, totally different 300 dpi file on totally different machine using PS CS3 also outputs a 72 dpi file. The latest version of Pixelmator software does the same thing.
Feb
8
comment All PDF's appear to be 72 dpi, no matter what
Same result in Photoshop CS3. Also tried Pixelmator with no luck.