2

Our UX designer uses Adobe XD to mock up and communicate look, layout and behavior to the dev team.

UX dev has everything in a single art board, which (AFAIK) is encapsulated in a single binary format .xd file on disk.

PROBLEMS:

  • Coders are assigned to specific screens/pages, and would like a more granular means of watching for changes to UI elements that they're responsible for. With a single file, they all have to watch for any changes, then read commit comments to determine whether their components were affected. This is tedious and error-prone.
  • Source code control systems lose a lot of their value when dealing with binary files; e.g. diffs, deltas, merging, etc.
  • What happens when multiple UX designers want to collaborate on a single art board?
  • By default, corporate IT policy often doesn't allow intellectual property (like new product designs) to be stored on the cloud.
  • Third-party solutions (e.g. Zeplin) also imply that our code/assets are no longer in a single place.

I saw at least one cloud-based collaboration tool used with XD (don't recall whether it was part of Adobe CC ecosystem or from a 3rd-party), but it didn't seem like it integrated with any source code control systems that a software organization might use.

EDIT #1:

Turns out that Adobe XD (.xd) files are just zip files (a zipped up copy of the project directory, I think), which is just what I'd expect to have checked into source control.

A quick-and-dirty short-term solution might be to have some automation on the source control server that triggers when the .xd file changes, unzips it to a staging dir, and then commits those files (keeping the commit comment) to what is essentially a read-only copy in source control.

QUESTION:

Does anyone use XD in conjunction with a source code control system like Git, SVN, TFS, GitLab, Mercurial, etc?

  • What is the actual question? it's a bit unclear: are you looking for a software recommendation or asking for a solution to a specific problem in your workflow? – Luciano Aug 6 '18 at 12:27
  • I'm just wanting to know if anyone stores their XD files in source control without losing all the granularity and other things mentioned above (and if so, how they do it). – Scott Smith Aug 6 '18 at 18:57

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.