5

I'm a self-taught graphic designer, I started some years ago making billboards because "you're the one who can use a computer" (I'm indeed a web developer) and since now I consider to have acquired some fine design feeling and skills.

I'm designing a logo for the newborn Student's Council of my University, in Italy. The council (CPS, Comitato Partecipativo degli Studenti, in Italian, translated as "Students' Participatory Committee") is headed by a student and is composed entirely of students.

The logo was conceived to embody the two main aspects of the committee:

  • It being for the students, by the students, modern and sensible to the student body inputs
  • It incorporating different "student parties" (as in political party) and uniting the students' representatives from all four of our departments.

The latter is symbolized by the four colors (which are the official colors of the four depts.) placed around the classic parlament hemicycle. The order of the colors was chosen by me to make it more visually pleasing.

The former is symbolized by the hemicycle, which looks like some sort of stylized "communication waves", much like the semicircles around antennas, and the downward slope of the text, which has the double purpose of making it more visually "captivating" and trying to make it stand out from classical institutional logos, and the font, rounder and more "friendly".

But, as I look at it, I cannot convince myself I've done a good job, while other friends of mine like it very much.

Is the color choice too much "colorful"? I fear that too many colors will render it unusable with non-white backgrounds.

Am I doing a terrible mistake by inserting a downward slope in the text?

I also cannot decide the correct spacing between the "C" and the hemicycle.

The logo will have a monochrome version for b/w prints and white-on-dark graphics.

the full color logo

Update

I've taken from both answers, and one of these will be the final logo. Thank you very much! I love stackexchange ❤️

straight version "to the infinity!" version

|improve this question
  • The 2 colored version shows that the thinner parting line does not work as well as it could. Alsondesign a pure black and white version – joojaa Mar 2 '19 at 17:06
10

I think you have a good logo at the conceptual level, but formally can improve.

The arcs formed by the colors and their subdivisions create virtual construction axes that are not reflected anywhere in the rest of the logo, there's no any coincidence, which clearly shows that the position is totally arbitrary. This is not wrong, but conceptually shows improvisation or something done carelessly:

enter image description here

Special attention to the letter C ends and the P lower horizontal stroke

Having four colors lines and four words in the text, is there any possibility to make some formal coincidence?

enter image description here

The inclination is informality, movement, dynamism, in cases of static logos, the action when stamping on a surface:

enter image description here

I don't know if in your logo works right. In the straight logo there are four directional axis what makes it already visually complicated. With the inclination you are adding a fifth one and stronger than the others:

enter image description here

If the inclination is up from left to right, the text axis gains more power and keeps the four original directional axis.

enter image description here

|improve this answer
  • You are totally right about arbitrarity: I'm a dog regarding formality and precision, I have zero formal instruction about graphics. About the downward slope, I chose it because it felt it was "following" the white spaces between the circle sectors, but I see how an upward inclination can make it more visually pleasing (thanks!). Wha do you mean by formal coincindence regarding colors? You mean something like associating each word with a colour? – Fabrizio Mele Mar 2 '19 at 13:03
  • Answer updated. – user120647 Mar 2 '19 at 13:12
  • 1
    thanks, I've considered your answer while tweaking, question updated – Fabrizio Mele Mar 2 '19 at 14:32
6

Symbolism:

Ordinary people who do not think waves nor communication, probably see a classical auditorium layout, where the committee is in the focus. That also can be an acceptable foundation for your shape.

Placements and orientations:

Move things to connect the texts and the colored curves, create a wandering route to the eye. Tilted appearance can be acceptable in your case but someone can see it as intentional slapdashness.

enter image description here

These are, of course, only opinions.

Not asked: There are some powerful or at least highly populated communities which also use colored stripes. Generally they have more colors, but be warned, that something like this will pop up soon by their and your enemies, if your color idea is taken into use:

enter image description here

Word partecipativo might be replaced with something perverse. People who want to cause troubles have only one etiquette: Maximize the trouble.

You can fight against it only beforehand. Let the well known version have less colors. I believe the blue-white one as the published version is safe.

|improve this answer
  • Thank you very much, I love the scaling, I updated the question with the result – Fabrizio Mele Mar 2 '19 at 14:32
  • 4
    I don't understand the rainbow bit and the p-word bit 🤔 – Fabrizio Mele Mar 2 '19 at 15:15
  • "powerful communities"? – R.. GitHub STOP HELPING ICE Mar 2 '19 at 23:24

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.