0

I am looking for GUI based software that allows me to draw shapes as the following in a book

Mathematica graphics

These are from chapter 2 of book by McGraw Hill Education. Called Heat and mass transfer. ISBN 978-0073398129

I tried contacting McGraw Hill asking what software they use to make such diagrams in their books but did not get answer.

I looking for software to draw such shapes. It needs to be GUI based (no programming). I saw a tag here for software recommendation so thought to ask, may be someone here can recognize what software could have made these or recommend something similar.

  • Most likely drawn by hand in illustrator, freehand etc. But i do not suggest using inkscape. And no tese are not engineering diagrams, but mathematical illustrations. – joojaa May 18 at 6:03
  • @joojaa have you something why the questioner should avoid Inkscape - some weaknesses, which probably cause problems? Just these images can be made in Inkscape without big difficulties. I know it hasn't proper CMYK print colors and the snapping point isn't exactly at the sharp tip of the arrowhead. – user287001 May 18 at 9:16
  • @user287001 well thing is if the user knew how to draw stuff like this they would not ask us. I dont suggest inkscape because I dont actually recommend it. Ye3ah in this case it has several weaknesses that really kill the bank. I mean hell using TikZ over inkscape is in thsi case warranted. – joojaa May 18 at 9:24
  • 1
    @joojaa the questioner wanted GUI, I guess he wants to avoid creating graphics by writing sentences in a description language. If I guessed right TikZ is just what the guestioner wants to avoid. Of course he can in the future change his mind and then a poor platform becomes an obstacle. Maybe the questioner would tell more. – user287001 May 18 at 9:37
  • @user287001 Im not saying you can not suggest inkscape I just say i can not suggest it because i dont recommend it for anything. I prefer to get things done, not have lots of features that have no ergonomics. If one is going to draw stuff like this one at minimum have to enjoy it. Sure Illustrator sucks ass but atleast it has 3 simplest ergonomics consideratons pinned down – joojaa May 18 at 9:40
3

These drawings can be made in vector graphics programs as 2D drawings. I'm sure that the result is usable without exact projection nor perspective. Thus one can draw circles as ellipses and other projected things without calculating the right projection details.

Here's one approximately as complex drawing made in Inkscape:

enter image description here

Inkscape is freeware. It's programmed by volunteers during a long time. This makes its user interface a little irregular when compared to Adobe Illustrator, but price=zero is a good reason to hold complaints.

Try Inkscape. It's a complex program, but work tutorials and have the user guide available.

If you make illustrations of math things, you need also formulas. In my drawing you see one attempt to insert them. They are not written in Inkscape, but exported from Microsoft's Equation editor.

In theory formulas are possible to be made as drawings, but in practice it's extremely difficult to place parts properly. Single line formulas can be sometimes written as text objects, but the result will very likely be inferior as soon as it's something more complex than A+B.

If you make a web search for "math formulas Inkscape" you'll find several writings of how to integrate LaTeX math typesetting to Inkscape. I haven't actually built such system, because the receipe is very complex. In addition Microsoft's system fits my purposes and quite low complexity tolerance. Unfortunately it's not faultless. If you check the formulas in my drawing carefully, you see easily irregular object placements and line thicknesses.

Easy to use math formula freeware:

It exists. Libre Office's drawing can be pasted to Inkscape and it stays editable. Unfortunately math formulas disintegrate to meaningless jumble when pasted to Inkscape as is. But there's a workaround. Converting formula to curves before copying and pasting prevents the explosion. That's not a big deal, because the editing would be in any case impossible in Inkscape. One must have the original formulas in a Libre Office Draw or Write document.

An example:

enter image description here

In the left there's a formula pasted to Inkscape "as is". In the right there's the same, but curved before cutting and pasting. I guess Libre Office's math symbol font "OpenSymbol" is somehow locked. Other programs can see it but cannot use it. Maybe there's a way to fix it.

2

These images are quite simple. Any 2D vector based program will do.

Free: Inkscape, Gravit Designer.

Paid: Corel Draw, Affinity Designer, Illustrator.

On each program, it could imply a slightly different way to do it.

Some of them have tools like a 3D extrusion for example. But it is not necessary. What you need to have in mind is to draw the basic shape and on this specific case, keep the proper lines parallel to what they are supposed to be parallel (Red). Duplicating the shape is a good start (Magenta)

enter image description here


If you first want to play a bit with the perspective or composition, in a real 3D environment explore Sketchup (free) or Blender (free) to play with it, make a screen capture and use it as a reference. But start with simple shapes first.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.