The left one is my turn on recreating the image seen on the right. I've found quite similar aluminum/metal material and played with the bevel to make it as similar as I could, but I can't replicate the light source.
As seen on the right, the top and bottom parts should be almost completely lit (white) and the sides should have more shadows. I tried playing with the light sources but really couldn't do anything similar to it. The one that I'm using right now is a spot light (disabled the infinite light). Maybe the issue is in the bevel as well?