0

I want to show user twelve options/buttons such that those options doesn't occupy too much space on screen.I don't want to show icon with each option as it will occupy more space.

The buttons contain various actions for Video Editing like cut,compress,reverse video etc.Above these options/buttons is a video player in which video is playing.

Below are the few designs which I made.Which design looks better from User Experience point of view?Any comments or suggestion are welcome!

Option 1-

enter image description here

Option 2-

enter image description here

Option 3-

enter image description here

Option 4-

enter image description here

  • 3
    If you want to make the interface more user friendly using colors you might try to gather the actions in some groups that can have slightly different colors. Using 12 different colors seems a bit too busy. – Wolff Sep 1 at 17:28
  • It's very challenging to give an aesthetic opinion or recommendation without seeing the entire aesthetic... i.e. need to see the whole UI, not just buttons. – Scott Sep 1 at 18:01
  • @Wolff All these twelve options are for video editing.So they belong to same category.So I think I should use same colour for all those options? – Android Developer Sep 1 at 18:22
  • I mean there must be some way to group those 12 options even though they are all about video editing. You mention "cut", "compress", "reverse". Those are not exactly equal. My guess is that you'll use "cut" all the time, "reverse" is more of a special effect and "compress" is for finalizing? – Wolff Sep 1 at 19:18
2

Which one do you prefer ?

You are slated with an issue of integrating form and function (aren't we all).

From a purely aesthetic viewpoint, I prefer # 3 or # 4. I find # 1 and # 2 to be very distracting with all the different colors- especially the lime green button on # 1- it does not seem to go with that more pastel color palette. The highly contrasting colors of #2 I do not like at all.

Perhaps you need the different colored buttons to differentiate the various functions easily for the user? It is really very subjective. Without seeing your entire project layout it is impossible to give any kind of definitive answer to your question. And even with the entire project knowledge, each answer will be unique to each person answering.

So I return to my original question- Which one do you prefer ? You have the information you need to weigh form and function. I say make your choice and go with it.

| improve this answer | |
0

i think you can categorise the actions? that might make it easier to find the action they want to take.

also, you might want to look at Snapseed, Google's photo editing app, as an inspiration for how they managed to put so many buttons in one screen.

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.