0

This started as just a bit of a joke when my partner this morning accidentally said,
"Shall we watch Boris Gump tonight?"
When I'd stopped laughing I stole ermm… borrowed some imagery from the interwebz to make up 'that picture' from the movie.

enter image description here

I quickly tidied up some extraneous 'noise' & people from the background, as it was going to conflict with my added title, & also poor Tom's head got similar treatment.

enter image description here

I got a pic of the alluded-to politician, facing approximately the same way, so head, shoulders, neck twist ought to match up. Some drastic resizing, a mask & some edge feathering & I plonked him in place.

enter image description here

A hopeless lighting match, of course, but beggars can't be choosers.

All to do now was to try to get the picture quality & lighting to match. Boris's head was a great deal sharper overall than the movie frame.
I re-shaped the lighting to try better match the rear sun & front soft light fill with airbrush, dodge & burn, colour-matched to the best of my ability & softened both Boris & background until they are an almost match for overall 'image quality'.
An hour or so later I had this. It's kind of OK but it's not really that convincing.

enter image description here

It still doesn't quite sit right to me.
It might be fine for your average Facebook post, but I feel there's more that I could have done.
Is there something I missed, or am I biased because I know it's "photoshopped" & keep directly comparing to the original? Or is this just 'the best you can hope for' from such disparate image sources?
Of course, the more I look at it, the more I'm bothered by such as the front soft light pushing Forrest's shadow to camera left, even though the sun is low & back left...

My original images are larger than this & the above are just screen shots from Ps, but I think the overall look is preserved to demonstrate the issue.
The work was done in the last Ps CC 2020 Mac (not looked at 2021 yet).

After comments
I pushed the lighting harder left & removed some additional distractions behind the feathering. Better but still missing something.

gif of before/after lighting changes.

enter image description here

New composite.

enter image description here

2
  • (great my whole comment went to waste) It's the hair. Hanks and Williams har are black. Hers are wavy and in contrast to white and geometrical statue in the background. His are in contrast due to shave lines. Your Boris have hair that don't show black background but also block the light on his forehead (compare to Hanks). I would thin the comb and add two light streaks on his forehead and nose. Dec 14 '20 at 13:49
  • @SZCZERZOKŁY - Pushed some more highs into camera left, tricked up some of the background to prevent jarring clashes in the feathering. better perhaps, but there's still something missing. I added a gif of the overall lighting changes I made & a new composite.
    – Tetsujin
    Dec 14 '20 at 17:25
1

The face of BG points to different direction and there's no direct sunlight. Your grabbed face doesn't need new highlights nor shadows except the back hair must be darker. The corner where some gloss could occur is hidden.

In higher resolution the situation can be different.

I tested light and color matching by inserting 3 masked adjustment layers and having a floating reference for side by side comparing. BG needs more contrast (Curves 1) and the saturation must be reduced (Hue&Saturation). Layer Curves 2 makes the back hair darker to make it less offensive against the dark background.

enter image description here

The light and color matching doesn't give more. The next step would be warping the face expression to show more interest. I consider the light and color matching gives only the starting point to the really interesting Photoshopping - making the photo to lie (or tell) what a person thinks.

Making this BG to have a smile needs a higher resolution image and some real talent. As a workaround I would start from a shot which has more ready to use non-technical qualities - like this:

enter image description here

My opinion is that as a joke it will do its job well as soon as the face expression and the geometric placement are ok. Also there's no need to degrade the head of BG. The result would be better if you adjust the colors of the original movie grab because people have seen the owner of BG's face in well lit and colorful onscreen news photos:

enter image description here

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.