It's best not to copy. Steal design ideas instead. Just flat out steal them, the best bits you need.
In order to do that you need to learn what constitutes each element of a design.
For example there's a very nice gradient inside the lettering of the HATTERAS VILLAGE text and a well weighted white outline, and a drop shadow.
Gradient = the inner colours of each letter in this section, it's the transition (top to bottom) from medium blue to a chrome-like white, to a hard edge of dark blue that then fades to a lighter shade of the same dark blue. It's got a wave going through the transition point.
The White Outline is the White line around each letter, and the drop shadow is the darker "shadow" that gives the perception the letters are slightly above the page.
Learning how to do this, and then experimenting with fonts and weights of those fonts with these things will give you enormous power.