Tools: Adobe Shape (mobile), Photoshop CC 2015 (Mac)

I have a library of shapes imported into Adobe Shape on my iPad. When I drag the shape into Photoshop CC 2015, it is imported as black lines. I cannot figure out how to change the shape to a different color. When I double click, I get the error message "This item isn't directly editable in Photoshop, but it can be placed in a document."

It seems to me that this limits the functionality ... are we expected to also buy Illustrator just to change an object to a different color?

I have been using Photoshop (as a photographer, not a graphic designer) since about 1992, so this shouldn't be a newbie question.



Adobe Shape

Adobe Shape items are vector files. Essentially the Shape app takes a photo, then uses some combination of the photocopy/threshold/cutout filter from Photoshop and image trace from Illustrator to create a vector shape.

Shape library items are placed as linked images in Photoshop, so they reference the actual library in the "cloud" or the sync'ed library on your system.

You can edit color of the entire shape, or rather apply a color, with any number of methods in Photoshop - Layer Style overlays, clipping layers, etc. This should work well if you just want to change the entire object to a single color or gradient. It's only an issue if you want to create a multi-colored object. Then you need to get into masking and overlays. Since you have the shape, generating well-defined masks shouldn't be too difficult. However, you can not alter the original shape data (color) with Photoshop, The same way you can't alter linked Illustrator documents with just Photoshop.

If you want to edit the vector shapes, you do need Illustrator. In Illustrator the Adobe Shape library items are just standard vector objects and allow any alteration to them. They are placed as live vector objects with no link to the Shape libraries directly.

Note that even with illustrator you can't open placed Shape images from Photoshop. You have to launch AI, and then place the Shape Library item to alter it, then re-save as a new file.

Photoshop is merely not designed to edit vector images directly and Adobe Shape is specifically designed to create vector images.

Possible workaround for not having Illustrator....

The mobile app Adobe Comp will let you place a Library item and alter its color. (Note the mobile app Adobe Illustrator Draw will not work, I tried it.)

enter image description here

  • Open a new Comp project
  • Place your library item
  • Select the item
  • Change the color
  • Use the send icon.. enter image description here to Send to Photoshop CC

This will open the comp image in Photoshop on your desktop. (Assuming the Adobe CC account is the same for the mobile apps and the desktop apps.)

The only issue with this is the Comp project opens on an artboard in Photoshop, so you will see a white background.

Just drag the layer for the shape outside the Artboard group in the Layers Panel and you'll have a layer with a changed color, still vector, and a transparent background, all without Illustrator.

It's a few extra steps, and the shape will no longer be linked to your shape library, but it does get around the cost of Illustrator.

For my money, using Comp to alter the color of the shape is much more complicated than simply applying a color overlay Layer Style within Photoshop. But I don't fully understand why you'd need to alter the color of the shape itself in the first place.

  • Scott, thanks for the comprehensive answer. Everything I capture via Adobe Shape seems to be converted to black and white regardless of the color of the original. I have some homework to do now ... I'll check Shape to see if I'm missing an option and I'll learn how to use the Photoshop techniques to color. This was great info, thanks!! – paul Jun 20 '15 at 20:48
  • @paul You aren't missing any options. Shape only creates black and white vector shapes. That's how it is designed. – Scott Jun 20 '15 at 20:59

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.