1

I've just drawn these two conceptual spheres in Adobe Illustrator:

enter image description here

I need to find the intersection of the yellow and blue spaces (and I'm not sure about my 3d intuition to acquire the right intersection, mentally!).

Is there any way Illustrator could do this?

  • I don't think so... You may need to use 3d max or something. It can give you the intersection automatically. Or someone with a powerful 3d intuition could tell you about the right answer! – A.Loc Jan 7 '17 at 0:56
3

Just deleted my former answer and its edits because it asked and quessed, but did not gave results.Here is a better one:

Illustrator can't give wanted result as 3D rendering, because this is an intersection of 2 volumes. Illustrator produces only one at a time and no combinations are possible in illustrator.

If the final volume could be produced equivalently as only one revolution or extrusion but maybe starting accordingly from more complex shape, then it would be possible to get perfect rendering from illustrator, too. But this is not the case. Those 2 volumes are sub 90 degrees revolutions, but around different axels. That makes the right pre-revolving combination nonexistent.

If another or both volumes were thin, like the last piece of a cake, then an approximate volume could be rendered in Illustrator. Thislike:

enter image description here

Generally correct result can only be got from 3D CAD software. The paid Sketchup is more than good enough, but also some high quality freebies exist. Note: Free Skethcup can't add, subtract or intersect 3D voulumes except only in some trivial cases.

A high quality 3D freebie is Design Spark Mechanical. The global electronic component dealer has put out their own heavily stripped version of SpaceClaim, which is a top notch non-parametric 3D direct modeller. Design Spark's version is still VERY powerful, altough a well thought set of features are disbled to prevent serious large scale pro applications. Some missing features:

  • assemblies
  • motion kinetics
  • automatic 2D drawings
  • realistic photographic rendering
  • materials for rendering and mass calculations
  • sheet metal
  • export & import as editable SpaceClaim compatible file

Much is off, but EUR 0,00 instead of EUR 2500,- creates deep pardon absolution and forgiveness.

The following solution of questioner's volume intersection popped out in 2 minutes; so easy is the interface if for example Sketchup is familiar.

enter image description here

viewing angle is selected for seeing 3 surfaces.

To complete the Illustrator version. I tried to add coordinate axels and one xy plane circle as a bed for the volume. It was so annoying that I gave up. In 3D it's possible to insert these and much more needed detail easily. When they are ready, the finale in Illustrator is an easy overdraw job.

| improve this answer | |
  • @user287001 Maybe we should take this to chat – joojaa Jan 9 '17 at 11:20
2

Illustrator has no concept of volumes, in general. Though it odes have a revolve tool that can do this for you. In either case doing the projection yourself is not that hard. If you really need to be able to cut volumes use a 3D MCAD application (Creo, Catia, Solidowrks, Inventor, or Fusion 360 which is free for small organisations), dump the lines to illustrator and then continue.

You can do this with revolve, its a bit of work. Just revolve a shape 2 times other time a fraction of 360 degrees. Unbfrotunately revolve does not allow you to choose direction easily. So it might or might not work out for you.

enter image description here

Image 1: Revolve tool allows you to make revolved objects. But it is unsuitable for general tasks.

Projecting yourself is not very hard. All you need to know is the SSR method. Or in fact general linear projection. Better tools exist im not going into this here since its a bit tedious to explain to those that didn't study protective geometry, but its no harder than looking up values in 2 separate pictures.

enter image description here

Image 2: Moving to a true 3d application gives you more options. You can still use illustrator for final tweaking.

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.