I think the Warp Arc Effect still works, you just need to refine the settings to get a closer match. If you add a small negative vertical distortion, it helps sell the effect. Then you can move the lines around to line them up.

[![Warp Effect][1]][1]

If you spend more time, I'm sure you could get almost an exact match.

  [1]: https://i.sstatic.net/Zx4dZ.gif