5

A bit of background:

I am a technical writer who as a result of corporate restructuring has become the “illustrator” for our Technical Publications department (we previoulsy had the services of a "real" graphic designer). I am completely self trained in using CorelDRAW X5 and (a little time with) Illustrator; save for a few tutorial videos I have watched and browsing forums such as this for guidance. I wouldn’t say I’m a novice, but I certainly don’t consider myself to be an advanced user either.

When our company re-organized, our department inherited the responsibility of making updates to technical manuals that another division had created. This location used a standard blue rounded-rectangle (with a stroke and drop shadow) as a background for all of the graphics used in their documents. There is an Illustrator file that contains about a dozen of these rectangles all with the same width (the intent is that this width is never to be adjusted) and varying heights. Occasionally, a graphic will fall “in between” two of these pre-made rectangles, but resizing it vertically (using the Direct Select tool) and maintaining the corner radius is simple enough. Unfortunately, during a recent office move the PC that had Illustrator crashed. We don’t have the hard copy of the software, and long story short, we’re not going to get it from the folks who do. The company can’t/won’t purchase a new version of Illustrator, so my only option going forward is Corel.

Opening the AI file with Corel breaks the rectangle into a group consisting of three distinct parts: blue rectangle with a stroke (as a curve), a separate stroke (as multiple curves), and drop shadow (as a bitmap). If using one of the pre-made rectangles, this isn't really an issue. The issue arises when my drawing is too tall for one rectangle, but would leave too much empty space (top and bottom) when using the next higher option. Unfortunately, vertically re-sizing the group causes the corner radius on the rectangle/stroke to distort.

Re-creating the rounded rectangle in Corel is simple enough; but despite hours of effort trying numerous combinations of presets, X & Y offsets, transparency, and feathering, I cannot match the drop shadow from the original AI file. I am beyond frustrated, as I would love nothing more than to have one rectangle that I could just re-size vertically as needed.

I’m hoping that someone here can help me either create a rectangle in Corel that will match the original, or perhaps just enlighten me as to how to make the one I have do what I want it to do.

Thanks in advance for any guidance/assistance, and my apologies for the novel.

For reference, the particulars on the rectangle (in Illustrator) are as follows:

  • .125” corner radius
  • Fill - uniform, R200, G218, B227
  • Stroke - 1pt, R 206, G170, B122
  • Drop Shadow:

    o X offset: .02 inches

    o Y offset: .02 inches

    o Blur: .05

    o Opacity: 75%

    o Layering: Multiply

    o Color: Black

AI File

CDR File

  • 1
    just how many hours do you think you need to try to solve this problem before its cheaper to buy illustrator? besides your license is not tied to one computer. – joojaa Feb 24 '15 at 21:16
  • You're preaching to the choir. Basically, we got a computer from a location that was closed, which had Illustrator installed on it. The actual software was at another location. That other location isn't part of our "group" anymore, and basically told us to pound sand. Maybe the funding gods will smile on me in the new year and Illustrator will magically appear on my desk; but I'm not holding my breath. – RoobyDooby Feb 24 '15 at 21:42
  • Your not actually supposed to compensate for bad management decissions. give out the ones that look different and say its best you can do. then let the management take it or leave it. – joojaa Feb 24 '15 at 21:58
  • Thanks for the feed back, @joojaa. I was just hoping that maybe someone could point out a solution that I hadn't tried, or that perhaps I was just missing an easy fix (due to my limited proficiency with the software). I agree that at some point it makes sense to just throw in the towel and move on - this post is my last attempt to make it work before doing just that. – RoobyDooby Feb 25 '15 at 13:35
1

Using the info in another post I stumbled across, I was able to achieve a very close match (see image). I finally settled on the following Corel drop shadow settings:

Preset: Small Glow

X offset: 0.02

Y Offset: -0.02

Opacity: 75%

Feathering: 3

Direction: Middle

Edge: Squared

Transparency Operation: Multiply

I'm still fiddling around with the exact color to use (true black seemed to be a bit dark), but I'd say it's a close enough match that I'm satisfied.

It seems that the "Direction" and "Edge" options were what I needed to adjust to achieve the desired results.

enter image description here

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.